Trunk comparison: BMW X4 vs VW Caddy Wagon

Key Differences

The BMW X4 offers a trunk that is 22 in (48%) longer with the seats folded down than the VW Caddy Wagon.

The VW Caddy, on the other hand, has a trunk opening that is 17.3 in (63%) higher and at its narrowest point a width that is 5.1 in (13%) greater than the X4. Additionally, the depth of the trunk (from loading edge to trunk floor) in the BMW X4 is 2.4 in (300%) higher, and the loading edge of the X4 is 8.7 in (39%) higher above the ground.

Impact on Usability

Long and flat cargo: Due to the significantly longer cargo space with the seats folded down, the BMW X4 is better suited for long, flat items (e.g., boards, long boxes, skis) when the rear seats are folded.

Tall and bulky cargo: The significantly higher trunk opening of the VW Caddy and the larger minimum width make it better suited for tall, bulky, or cubic items that need to be loaded straight or standing up (e.g., boxes, furniture parts, plants).

Loading comfort and handling heavy loads: The significantly lower loading edge of the VW Caddy makes lifting and rolling heavy or awkward items easier. The 8.7 in higher loading edge of the BMW X4 increases the effort required when loading.

Trunk organization: The greater depth in the BMW X4 means more space below the loading edge (e.g., for secured items or lower compartments), but it can restrict placing very large/rectangular items in combination with the lower opening and narrower track.

Conclusion: For long, flat cargo with occasional transport, the BMW X4 is advantageous. For frequent loading and unloading, transporting tall or bulky items, and easier access when lifting heavy loads, the VW Caddy Wagon is more practical.