Trunk comparison: VW Caddy Wagon vs VW Golf Wagon (Mk5)

Key Differences (highlighted: >10%)

The VW Golf 5 offers a 21.3 in (47%) longer trunk when the seats are folded down compared to the VW Caddy Wagon. The trunk opening of the Caddy, however, is significantly higher: +15.7 in (54%) compared to the Golf. The trunk depth (loading edge → trunk floor) is +1.2 in (150%) greater in the Golf.

The loading edge of the Golf is +2.8 in (12%) higher above the road than that of the Caddy.

In width, the Caddy has advantages: The narrowest point in the trunk is +5.1 in (13%) wider and the width of the trunk opening is +4.7 in (12%) larger than the Golf. (The difference with the front seats upright of +0.8 in / 2% is minor and was not highlighted.)

Impact on Usability

The longer cargo area of the Golf with folded seats makes it suitable for long, flat loads (e.g., slats, long boxes, skis). This is a clear advantage when regularly transporting longer items.

The Caddy, due to the significantly higher trunk opening (+15.7 in) and greater width at the opening and narrowest point (+12 / +5.1 in), is better suited for bulky, wide, or tall items that need to be loaded standing up or pushed in sideways (e.g., furniture, appliances, crates).

The higher opening facilitates loading taller items.

The slightly greater trunk depth measurement in the Golf (+1.2 in) means minimally more loading length in depth; however, since it is only +1.2 in absolute, the practical gain is limited despite the high percentage value.

The +2.8 in higher loading edge of the Golf increases the effort required to lift heavy loads inside compared to the Caddy (the Caddy’s lower loading edge is easier on the back when loading).

In summary: For long, flat cargo, the Golf 5 is advantageous. For bulky, wide, or tall cargo and easier handling of heavy items, the Caddy Wagon is the more practical choice.